The Chosen One
Some of our favorite stories revolve around the idea of the Chosen One, in which a (usually reluctant or conflicted) hero is selected to save the world. Frodo Baggins and Harry Potter are two examples that fly to mind, but there have been countless iterations. When a trope is done and redone repeatedly, it begs the question: why is this particular storyline so appealing to readers?
Typically, an “everyman” type character assumes the role of the Chosen One, and his or her averageness allows us to easily position ourselves in their shoes. I believe, though, that our attraction to the Chosen One trope goes deeper than the everyman theory. I think it appeals to modern readers because it presents an answer to the burden of choice.
People crave options and relish the ability to make choices. However, in today’s world, they are inundated with seemingly infinite possibilities everywhere they turn, whether they are buying a new pair of shoes or deciding on a career path. While having an abundance of choice seems like a positive thing, the more choices there are, the more effort is required to sort through them, and the greater the potential for regret over the decision. The burden of choice can result in malaise, dissatisfaction and choice paralysis.
In literature, the Chosen One character is exempt, in many ways, from this burden of choice, because he or she has a clear responsibility to fulfill - a singularity of purpose that creates an easier environment for making choices. In order to defeat the villain/save the world, he or she will find it easy to make the choice that will further their monolithic goal. It’s a bit of escapism for the reader, because wouldn’t it be nice if Hagrid showed up, whisked us away on a flying motorcycle, and pointed out to us our one true purpose in life? (Personally, I would sign up for this type of aggressive life-coaching in a heartbeat - just tell me what to do!) Sometimes, the Chosen One trope is criticized for this very reason - it renders the plot too simplistic and diminishes the agency of the Chosen One character - yet, it continues to resonate with readers.
In real life, as the main characters of our own stories, we can limit the burden of choice by determining our governing values. What values are most important to us? Career success? Familial harmony? We may not have the predetermined paths of Chosen Ones, but by clearly understanding our own values and making choices that align with them, we can more easily find satisfaction in our decisions.
Or we can escape into a book. Good luck picking a title out of your TBR stack!